[PhantomBlood]

I've seen countless times people complaining about guild storage raiding, honestly as a guild leader myself I'm tired of it. GS raiders need morals but since that is never the case I think guild leaders should be given control over who can enter the guild storage if possible. My suggestion is:

Such as with giving rights to Invite and Expel I suggest a new option be added to enable/disable guild storage access thus preventing newbies who could also be alt chars of opposing guilds from entering your guild, raiding your GS and leaving. I've seen it so many times and nothing done about it cause nothing can be done about it, all we get told as leaders is "be careful who you invite" well we all are and sometimes that's not always enough. I think that option would solve an annoying problem. Let me know what you guys think of this.
_________________

[Glenfiddich]

How's about a password protected gstorage? If it is possible that is. And that way you can give password to maybe trusted members of guild

Good idea though hawk
_________________
Characters-

Glenfiddich; 255- Professor
Jager Bomb; 255- Creator
Rammstein; 255- Creator

[xblackcatz]

I've seen this work in other mmorp's, it works well and will also work as building up trust with the guild leader as well as the rest of the guild.
_________________


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
CHARACTERS:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Priest - Catnip
Lord Knight- Jynxi
High Wizard - Evallina
Whitesmith - Neko Mimi

[wolfsdhorm]

well there's the problem again with your idea, hawk. you could end up thinking you can trust the person then once you give them GS privilage, they could raid it, and same goes with your idea, glen. i say that only Guild Leader should be allowed to access it to take things out but people still allowed to access it and put things in. im just pointing out the faults so don't hate me and my idea is simply an opinion...i do agree, however, that the GS raiding has to stop
_________________


Nuriko's Creations

Hate me, Cut me, Date me, Love me. Your choice

[PhantomBlood]

There's no problem with my idea, the only time a GS would get raided if my idea was implemented is if the GL was an idiot and gave access to EVERYONE right away. If this suggestion comes to pass and I have the option to give access, only my core members would get it and after that it would take a very long time for me to give it to anyone else because they'd have to earn my trust. That's how raiding is prevented, raids will only happen to guilds who grant access to new people in their guild in which case it really will be their own fault.
_________________

[wolfsdhorm]

yes i see your point. but your still forgetting...people can act extremly well on games. so people from the rival guilds can go through that very long time to earn your trust and then raid your guild...there is a possiblity that they might change their mind on what they are doing but still
_________________


Nuriko's Creations

Hate me, Cut me, Date me, Love me. Your choice

[Glenfiddich]

Passworded gstorages would at the very least minimise problems. And if things do go missing, at least you have an idea of who took. Not only that, but if you held someone in high enough regard to give them the password, I am sure they wouldn't mind if a few things started disappearing. Much better gears going to people you trust and not someone you don't know.
_________________
Characters-

Glenfiddich; 255- Professor
Jager Bomb; 255- Creator
Rammstein; 255- Creator

[wolfsdhorm]

but remember...enemy guild member's alts...if they are dedicated enough they will go thru whatever to get to the GS...all these idea's would minimize GS raids...but thing is which would be the BEST at minimizing GS raids
_________________


Nuriko's Creations

Hate me, Cut me, Date me, Love me. Your choice

[PhantomBlood]

Ok well why don't you support your theory, you have a better idea than I do let's hear it? I never said my suggestion would completely eliminate raids but I can personally guarantee it would dramatically reduce it.
On top of that with the ability to choose who can access it you can better find out who the raider is, there are no down sides to implementing this option
_________________

[wolfsdhorm]

your right, now downsides in FINDING who took it...makes it easier to find out who raided you. but raids will still continue...if the GL is the only one who can access the GS no raids will happen...may irritate some people but no raiding would happen...you know ._. forget about my idea...i just realized the biggest fault it in...people will be VERY irritated if my idea was implemented
_________________


Nuriko's Creations

Hate me, Cut me, Date me, Love me. Your choice

[Glenfiddich]

Phantom, your idea is good. There are no downsides in this suggestion.

It's like putting a lock on a safe. If the lock is there, it is a deterrant for people to steal anything. If they are so intent to take something, they always will. Having the deterrant there though will solve the problem to a small degree, which is good enough IMO
_________________
Characters-

Glenfiddich; 255- Professor
Jager Bomb; 255- Creator
Rammstein; 255- Creator

[radeld]

or better yet why not have the gstorage like vending machine where you put in x money (set by gleader) to take out items and only gleader can give items in gstorage for free
_________________

IGN TIME!!!
Hidden doom
Doomed healed
doom cast
dancing fool
and any other ppl with "doom" in their name
or in the outside world i'm known as Danny...

[wolfsdhorm]

well then too many people would be starting guilds to try and get the rich people in and get to good gear so that they can become rich...causing reign to go pretty heywire...how combining both glen's and phantom's ideas? GL can allow people access to the GS but you can put password on anything you don't want people to just take out of the blue
_________________


Nuriko's Creations

Hate me, Cut me, Date me, Love me. Your choice

[lildevil]

I really don't see the downfall from Sdhorm point of view due to the fact how many people have enough patience to suck up in a guild they hate? Also, not to mention it's not like any guild is stupid enough to put their MVP cards in there to share. Let's be honest human being are selfish creature, if we don't have "extra" we wouldn't share with just anyone? The amount of patience a person must go through to get into the guild storage is some what pointless.... Just like Krimson pointed out only his "Core" members are along; in theory, this mean they are trusting friend that can share their items. I really don't understand your point of view, sorry Sdhorm. Everybody have a different point of view. I see a downfall in this system, but it's not as big as what you stated. My only problem with this idea is how will the other members feel when they know that even if they're in the same guild, but they're just not in the same group. This is not a problem of a guild raid anymore, but instead of a guild breakdown. Yes, there is always a certain group that closer to the guild leader, but don't you think having another option to split the guild into a group will cause more of a break down? This is my own view so I'm trying to put anyone down.

[corona]

i like this idea, although its never affected me personally, i've known other people who have had the GS raided. like most people have said already, this will not stop GS raids but it will minimize them, people wont just have to get into a guild then take everything, they will have to earn the GL trust, and IMO, thats just a damn waste of time to take a few things...
_________________


Corona - 255 Stalker
Tooheys - 255 High Wizard